In today’s technology-driven households, batteries power everything from remote controls to smoke detectors, children’s toys to emergency flashlights. The Gardner Bender GBT-500A Analog Battery Tester presents itself as a solution to a common household dilemma: determining which batteries still have life and which should be recycled. With its ability to test multiple battery types ranging from tiny button cells to larger lantern batteries, this tester promises to be a versatile addition to any home toolkit. But does it deliver on its promises? This comprehensive review examines the GBT-500A’s design, functionality, accuracy, and overall value to help you determine if this is the battery tester your household needs.
Design and Build Quality
Physical Characteristics
The Gardner Bender GBT-500A features a compact design that’s smaller than many users expect. Approximately the size of a soda can, this analog tester features a clean, functional aesthetic with a clear analog display that doesn’t require batteries to operate—an ironic but practical advantage for a battery tester. The unit comes with two attached wire leads with probe tips for testing and features metal contacts on the front face for 9V batteries.
Materials and Construction
The tester is constructed primarily of plastic, but most users report that it feels well-made and pleasing to use despite the economical materials. The matte finish on the marked panel surrounding the dial adds a professional touch to the otherwise utilitarian design. The attached wire leads are described as pliable but lack strain relief at the connection points, which could potentially become a durability issue over time.
Control Features
The device features a rotating dial selector with 9 positions for different battery types, a needle display with color-coded zones (red for “replace,” yellow for “weak,” and green for “good”), and a red button specifically designed for testing button cells. A small kickstand on the back provides stability when setting the unit down, though some users note that only one of the two lugs properly engages.
Functionality and Features
Testing Range
The GBT-500A is remarkably versatile, capable of testing an impressive array of battery types. The 9 selectable battery types include:
- Button Cell 1.5V
- AAA-N-1.5V
- AA-C-D-1.5V
- Lithium 3V
- 6V
- 9V
- 12V
- 15V
- 22.5V
This extensive range makes the tester suitable for virtually any household battery, from tiny watch batteries to larger lantern cells.
Operating Mechanism
What sets this tester apart from a simple voltmeter is its ability to place an appropriate load on the battery during testing. This is crucial for accurate assessment of battery health, as a battery’s voltage under load is a much better indicator of its actual performance than its open-circuit voltage. The GBT-500A achieves this through an array of internal resistors that apply different loads appropriate to each battery type.
According to the specifications provided in the manual, the device applies the following load currents and uses the following voltage thresholds for the “GOOD” indication:
- Button Cell 1.5V: 1 mA load, 1.125V minimum for “GOOD”
- AAA-N-1.5V: 50 mA load, 1.125V minimum for “GOOD”
- AA-C-D-1.5V: 150 mA load, 1.125V minimum for “GOOD”
- Lithium 3V: 1 mA load, 2.25V minimum for “GOOD”
- 6V: 10 mA load, 4.50V minimum for “GOOD”
- 9V: 10 mA load, 6.75V minimum for “GOOD”
- 12V: 10 mA load, 9.00V minimum for “GOOD”
- 15V: 10 mA load, 11.25V minimum for “GOOD”
- 22.5V: 10 mA load, 16.875V minimum for “GOOD”
These varied load currents are designed to simulate real-world usage appropriate to each battery type—lighter loads for small button cells and heavier loads for batteries commonly used in high-drain devices.
Ease of Use
Basic Operation
Using the tester is straightforward: select the appropriate battery type using the dial, then place the probes against the positive and negative terminals of the battery. The needle will then move to indicate the battery’s condition in the color-coded zones.
Testing Different Battery Types
While the concept is simple, the execution varies depending on the battery type:
For standard cylindrical batteries (AA, AAA, C, D): Many users find it somewhat awkward to hold the battery while simultaneously positioning both probes against the terminals. A popular workaround is to place the positive end of the battery against the 9V positive contact on the face of the tester, then use only the black (negative) probe to touch the negative end of the battery. This technique is mentioned in the manual but easy to overlook.
For button cells: The tester includes a special feature—a red button on the face with a slot underneath where you can place the button cell, then press down to take measurements. This is much easier than trying to position the probes on the tiny contacts of these small batteries.
For 9V batteries: In theory, these can be tested using the metal contacts on the face of the unit. However, some users report that the 9V contacts are poorly designed, with the spacing not quite matching standard 9V battery terminals, requiring some manipulation to get good contact.
Learning Curve and Adaptations
Several users mention that there is a slight learning curve to using the GBT-500A effectively. Many develop their own systems to make testing easier, such as using alligator clips to modify the probes, using tape to secure small batteries during testing, or developing specific holding techniques to maintain stable contact.
Accuracy and Performance
Accuracy Assessment
The GBT-500A earns praise from many users for providing more accurate readings than simple voltmeters or cheaper testers that don’t apply appropriate loads. The application of a load during testing is crucial for simulating real-world conditions and getting a true picture of battery performance.
However, opinions on the tester’s accuracy are somewhat mixed:
Some users find that the tester is not as precise as they would like, noting that the meter’s scale could be better designed. Several mention that a fully charged battery typically reads at the “G” in “GOOD” rather than at the far right of the scale, leaving a relatively small arc of movement between a full battery and a marginal one.
Others have had more negative experiences, with one user reporting being unable to get readings more than 20% into the “Good” range even with new batteries showing 1.55V on a multimeter.
Despite these criticisms, many experienced users, including some who identify as electrical engineers, find that the analog meter provides nuanced information that digital displays cannot match. They note that it’s not just the final position that matters, but also how the meter moves—the way it “pops” and swings rapidly with a good battery versus the sluggish movement of a weak one.
Comparison to Other Testing Methods
Multiple reviewers who own more sophisticated testing equipment still find value in the GBT-500A, with one electrical engineer noting that despite having fancy testers/chargers/dischargers and multiple high-end voltmeters, “sometimes the little GB tester gives a better feeling for what is going on with a battery.”
Durability and Reliability
Long-term Performance
Many users report impressive longevity from the GBT-500A, with several mentioning that their previous identical or similar models lasted 10-20 years with regular use. This suggests robust internal components despite the economical construction.
However, there are also reports of premature failures, most commonly involving the wire leads becoming disconnected. Some users have experienced this issue within just a month of purchase, while others report years of trouble-free use.
Warranty and Support
The product comes with a one-year warranty from the manufacturer. Some users report positive experiences with customer service, mentioning quick replacements when issues were reported.
Value Assessment
Price-to-Performance Ratio
Priced typically between $10-15, most users consider the GBT-500A to offer excellent value. As one reviewer put it, “For a cheap tool it provides a good bang for the buck.” While not professional grade, most find it perfectly adequate for home use when handled with reasonable care.
Cost Savings Potential
Several users point out that the tester quickly pays for itself by preventing the premature disposal of good batteries and avoiding the purchase of unnecessary replacements. One grandfather specifically mentioned how helpful it was in testing batteries his grandchild had removed from devices, finding that about 50% of those discarded as “no good” were actually still well within the “good” range.
Alternatives Comparison
For those seeking more precise measurements, some reviewers recommend the INNOVA 3320 Auto-Ranging Digital Multimeter, which costs slightly more but offers actual voltage readings and still includes a load-testing function for batteries. However, for most household users, the simplicity and adequate accuracy of the GBT-500A make it a compelling choice.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Tests batteries under load for more accurate results than simple voltage readings
- Versatile—tests 9 different battery types across a wide voltage range
- No batteries required for operation
- Special feature for testing button cells
- Potentially long lifespan of 10+ years
- Analog display provides nuanced information about battery health
- Excellent value for the price
Cons
- Somewhat awkward to hold probes against battery terminals
- Poor design of 9V battery contacts
- Leads lack strain relief and may disconnect over time
- Scale design could be improved for better readability
- Some units may have calibration issues
- No protective case included
Ideal Users and Use Cases
The Gardner Bender GBT-500A is ideal for:
- Households with children who frequently replace batteries in toys and devices
- People who recycle batteries and need to sort good from bad
- Users who keep a stock of batteries and need to verify their condition
- Electronic hobbyists who appreciate the included circuit schematic in the manual
- Those who prefer analog simplicity over digital complexity
It’s less suitable for:
- Users who need precise voltage readings
- Those who require industrial durability
- People testing primarily high-drain devices like digital cameras
Tips and Tricks from Experienced Users
Several clever workarounds and tips emerge from user reviews:
- For cylindrical batteries: Rest the positive end on the 9V contact on the tester face and use only the negative probe for easier testing.
- For stable testing: Use alligator clips on the probes or place a piece of adhesive (like folded Scotch tape) on a flat surface to stabilize small batteries during testing.
- For more precise reference: Some users mark the position on the scale where a new battery typically reads (between the G and first O in “GOOD”) with a small red dot of paint or masking tape to quickly distinguish between new and used batteries.
- For troubleshooting fluctuating readings: If the needle fluctuates wildly, the battery contacts or tester leads may be dirty. Clean the contacts or scrape them back and forth slightly and test again.
- For interpreting results: If the needle movement is controlled but slowly decreases to the left, this indicates the meter’s test load is pulling the battery voltage down, suggesting the battery is failing.
Conclusion: A Valuable Tool with Minor Flaws
The Gardner Bender GBT-500A Analog Battery Tester represents excellent value for homes and hobbyists who need a simple, reliable way to test the wide variety of batteries used in modern devices. Its ability to test batteries under appropriate loads sets it apart from simple voltmeters and provides more meaningful results than open-circuit voltage readings.
While it’s not without flaws—the awkward probe positioning, potential durability issues with the leads, and sometimes confusing scale readings—most users find these minor inconveniences easily outweighed by the utility and cost savings the device provides. The potential longevity of 10+ years reported by many users further enhances its value proposition.
For those who find themselves regularly wondering whether batteries are still good or ready for recycling, the GBT-500A offers an economical, versatile solution that will likely pay for itself many times over through extended battery life and reduced unnecessary purchases. While more sophisticated options exist for those requiring precise measurements, for the average household, this tester strikes an excellent balance between functionality, simplicity, and affordability.
In the sage words of one reviewer, this is a device where “once you have one you will wonder why you didn’t buy one long, long ago.” Despite its modest price and occasional quirks, the Gardner Bender GBT-500A earns its place in any well-equipped home toolkit.
Buy on Amazon: Here
